South Texas Law Review

 

 


 

 

   
 

Frequently Asked Questions

I have a GPA of a 3.24. Can I join Law Review?

No. The South Texas Law Review will not make any exceptions to the minimum GPA requirement.

What is the workload like on Law Review?

During your Candidacy semester on Law Review, you will be assigned to an Articles Editor. This editor will give you assignments that involve finding and checking sources, making sure footnotes are properly cited, and checking text for errors in grammar, punctuation, etc. You will also be required to work on a student comment. This comment will be written over your four-semester commitment to Law Review. Please ask a Comment Editor for a detailed breakdown of the comment. Finally, each candidate will be assigned two weekly office hours. 

How many semesters do I need to be on Law Review?

There is a four-semester requirement for Law Review. You will not receive credit if you don't complete all four semesters.

Can I participate in Law Review for 2 or 3 semesters without receiving class credit?

No.

Are there a set number of spots to fill on Law Review?

No, there is no "set" number of spots on Law Review. The incoming number of candidates is based solely on the quality of work received and the needs of the journal at the time.

Law Review Write-On Competition FAQs

Do you recommend any sources to help work on the Write-On Competition?

The 19th Edition of the Bluebook and the current edition of the Greenbook are good places to start. There are several scholarly writing books as well. For example, the Manual on Usage and Style is a helpful tool. Also, the Comments published in the South Texas Law Review issues will help show the type of work we publish and look for.

Is the Table of Contents included in the page limit? Should it be on a separate page?

Yes, the Table of Contents is included in the Write-On Competition's page limit. It should not, however, be on a separate page from the rest of the paper.

Do you only edit the text or footnotes in the editing exercise?

Assume that nothing is correct on the editing exercise. Fix anything that you believe needs to be fixed. Do not add or delete any footnotes in the editing exercise. We recommend that you work on this part of the Write-On Packet first, as it might help you when working on the case note.

Can I find sources other than the ones listed on the source list for the case note? Are all of the sources on the list relevant and cited accurately?

No. The case note has a closed source list. You can choose to use as many (or as few) of the sources as you would like on the note; however, you cannot add any additional sources. The Law Review does not ensure that all of the sources are cited accurately or are relevant. Hopeful candidates need to use their own judgment.

Can I have a professor review my Write-On Packet?

No. You cannot have any outside help when working on any part of the Write-On Packet. You will be disqualified from the competition if you receive outside help.

Will the Law Review board members be available to answer questions?

No substantive questions will be answered by the Law Review board.

How are the packets graded?

The case note and editing exercise are the focal parts of the competition. Each grader is given the same set of criteria with which to review every submission. GPA will also be a factor; however, it can only help a participant and can't hurt one. No student shall have access to another student's GPA.

How do I identify my packet? Will it be anonymous?

When you turn in your packet, do not place your name or a number on the packet. Your packet will be assigned a 4-digit number after you submit it. A Law Review administrator will have a log of which name and number go together, while the editors will only know what number to identify each packet with—they will never see your name. Students participating in the Write-On Competition won’t know their number, making the process “double blind.” Even when the results are posted, the editors will only know who successfully wrote on to Law Review, but not which paper went with each student.

When is the packet due?

Each competition has its own deadline. The Summer 2013 competition is due at 5:00 pm on May 31, 2013. Absolutely NO late papers will be accepted.

If I am mailing in my packet, is it OK if it arrives after the deadline if it is postmarked before then?

No. All packets must be received BY the deadline, regardless of how they are delivered.